When should I take Social Security?

Most retirees spend more time on this question than almost any other in retirement. It's a reasonable amount of energy to spend. Social Security benefits, for many households, represent hundreds of thousands of dollars in lifetime income, depending on when you start.

The problem isn't that the question is complicated. The problem is that most people approach it with the wrong goal in mind.

The question people usually ask

The most common framing is: "What's the break-even age?" Meaning — if I wait until 70 to claim instead of 62, how many years until I've collected more in total?

It's a reasonable question. But it leads to a narrow answer. Break-even analysis treats Social Security like a bet on how long you'll live. That's one factor — and it matters — but it's rarely the most important one, especially for married couples.

What actually shapes the decision

When you stop working. Social Security benefits are reduced if you claim before your full retirement age while still earning income above a certain threshold. If you're planning to work until 67, the calculation looks different than if you're stepping away at 62.

Your spouse's benefit. Married couples have more options than most realize. Because one spouse's benefit eventually becomes the survivor benefit when the other passes, coordinating when each of you claims can meaningfully increase lifetime household income — especially if there's a significant age gap or income difference between you.

Your tax situation. Up to 85% of Social Security benefits can be subject to federal income tax, depending on your combined income. If you have other income sources in retirement — IRA distributions, rental income, part-time work — the after-tax value of waiting or claiming early may look different than the gross numbers suggest. In some cases, a Roth conversion strategy in the years before Social Security begins can make the later years substantially more efficient.

Your other income sources. If you have a pension, significant investment accounts, or other guaranteed income, you may be in a position to delay Social Security and let the benefit grow. If your portfolio is the only bridge between stopping work and claiming benefits, that changes the math.

Your health and family history. This is the factor most people focus on — and it matters. But with an important nuance: if you're married, you're planning for both of you, not just yourself. Even if one spouse has health concerns that suggest a shorter life expectancy, delaying the higher earner's benefit can substantially increase the survivor's lifetime income if the healthier spouse lives into their late eighties.

How the decision looks in practice

Social Security benefits grow by roughly 6–8% per year for every year you delay claiming between 62 and 70. That's a guaranteed, inflation-adjusted return that's difficult to replicate elsewhere in a retirement portfolio.

For a high earner who delays from 62 to 70, the monthly benefit can be more than 75% higher. Over a long retirement, that difference compounds significantly — and it's a difference that passes to a surviving spouse.

The counterargument — claim early and invest the difference — is theoretically appealing and practically difficult. It requires taking on market risk to replicate a guaranteed outcome, and it doesn't fully account for the survivor benefit, taxes, or the behavioral difficulty of leaving money in a portfolio during a down market when you're also drawing income.

The honest answer

There is no universally right time to claim Social Security. The right answer depends on your health, your spouse's situation, your tax picture, your other income sources, and your goals.

What I find working through this with clients is that the decision usually becomes clear once you've modeled a few realistic scenarios side by side — not theoretical break-even math, but actual projections of household income, taxes, and what happens if one of you lives to 90.

If you're within five years of retirement and haven't looked at this carefully yet, it's worth doing before you make the call. The window to optimize closes once you start claiming.

---

WakePointe Wealth Advisors and LPL Financial do not provide legal advice or tax services. Social Security claiming decisions should be reviewed in the context of your full financial picture. Please consult your advisor regarding your specific situation.